Catering Menu Food By the Tray Catering

Now offering Contactless pickup. 
Our Food by the Tray menu is ideal for events at home, corporate office or other venues. Dishes are available in half tray or full tray portions unless otherwise noted. Half tray serves 12 persons, full tray serves 20 persons.
Your order will be available for pickup, hot and ready to serve.  Limited delivery service is also available with added delivery charges. 
We can also supply paper goods and disposable wire frames to keep food warm. Prices are subject to NYS Tax. Please place all catering orders at least 48 hours before your event.

Chicken Wings

Your choice of Honey Wings or (Spicy) Buffalo Wings
Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$90

Chicken Scarpariello

Chicken thighs with rosemary, garlic & wine sauce.
Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$120

Chicken Piccata

Lightly-floured chicken breast fried with lemon-caper sauce.
Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Chicken Scarpariello

Chicken thighs with rosemary, garlic & wine sauce.
Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$120

Chicken Kebab

Chicken thighs with rosemary, garlic & wine sauce.
Minimum 10 pieces.
per Kebab
$3.55

Chicken Parmesan

Breaded chicken breast with marinara, Parmesan, and mozzarella.
Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Southern Fried Chicken

Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$95

Grilled Chicken Breast w/ Artichoke & Sun-Dried Tomatoes

With white wine & garlic reduction.
Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$140

Chicken Marsala

Lightly-floured chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms.
Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$140

Beef Bourguignon (Burgundy)

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Sliced Grilled Steak

With peppers and onions.
Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$130

Homestyle Italian Meatballs Marinara

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Oxtail Stew

priced per market

Roast Beef

With mushroom gravy.
Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Homestyle Meatloaf with Gravy

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

BBQ Beef Ribs

Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$140

Swedish Meatballs

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Grilled Salmon

Half Tray
$70
Full Tray
$130

Stuffed Flounder

With vegetables and rice.
priced per market

Bassa Livornese

Fish with onions, tomatoes, capers, and olives.
Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$120

Seafood Paella

With mussels, clams, shrimp, chorizo (Spanish-style pork sausage), and calamari.
Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$150

Crab Cakes

Two pieces per person recommended.
Minimum 12 pieces.
per Piece
$2.90

Grilled Tuna Steak

priced per market

Tilapia Oreganata

Baked with parsley and breadcrumbs.
Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$125

Shrimp Scampi

Over cappellini
Half Tray
$85
Full Tray
$140

Mussels Sauté

With your choice of sauce
Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$75

Roast Loin of Pork

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

BBQ Pork Spare Ribs

Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$125

Pork Ossobuco

priced per market

Roast Suckling Pig

Minimum 20lbs.
priced per market

Pork Sausage

With peppers and onions
Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$100

Fresh Ham

per pound
$7.99

Fresh Pernil

Slow roasted pork.
per pound
$7.99

Baked Whole Spiral Ham

per Pound
$6.95

Veal Parmesan

Breaded veal cutlet with marinara, Parmesan, and mozzarella.
Half Tray
$80
Full Tray
$140

Veal Sorrentino

Veal with prosciutto, spinach, cheese.
Half Tray
$80
Full Tray
$140

Veal Marsala with mushrooms

Lightly-floured veal cutlet sauteed with mushrooms.
Half Tray
$80
Full Tray
$140

Veal Picatta

Lightly-floured veal cutlet fried with lemon-caper sauce.
Half Tray
$80
Full Tray
$140

Veal Osso Bucco

priced per market

Grilled Lamb Loin Chops

Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$125

Roast Leg of Lamb

per pound
$8.95

Grilled Lamb Kebabs

With white wine & garlic reduction.
per Piece
$5.25

Baked Ziti

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Cheese Ravioli Marinara

Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$100

Lasagna with Cheese

Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$130

Vegetable Lasagna

Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$140

Fettuccini Alfredo

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Pasta Primavera

Vegetables in white sauce.
Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$125

Farfalle with Mushroom and Truffle Oil

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Baked Ziti with Meat

Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$130

Stuffed Shells with Ricotta Marinara

Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$90

Lasagna with Meat

Half Tray
$75
Full Tray
$140

Penne ala Vodka

Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Tortellini alla Panna

With butter, egg and cream sauce.
Half Tray
$65
Full Tray
$125

Pasta with Grilled Sausage

With Broccoli Rabe Saute
Half Tray
$60
Full Tray
$120

Tossed Green Salad

With tomatoes, cucumber, onions.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$1.75

Assorted Field Greens Mesculin Salad

Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$2

Baby Arugula Salad

With beets, gorgonzola cheese, candied almonds.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$3.25

Sliced Tomato and Fresh Mozzarella

With basil oil.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$2.95

Tri-Color Salad

Endive, radicchio, arugula.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$2.95

Caesar Salad

With herbed croutons.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$3.25

Spinach Salad

With apples, strawberries, goat cheese, walnuts.
Minimum 10 servings.
per person
$3.25

Eggplant Rollatini

Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$95

Assorted Vegetable Sauté

Half Tray
$35
Full Tray
$60

Assorted Grilled Vegetables Platter

per pound
$9.95

Vegetable Rice

Half Tray
$35
Full Tray
$70

Sauteed Spinach

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Baby Glazed Carrots

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Roasted Herb Potatoes

Half Tray
$35
Full Tray
$65

Pasta Salads

Your choice of Vegetable, Pesto or Mediterranean
per pound
$5.95

Potato Salad

per pound
$3

Red Skin Potato Salad

per pound
$4

Assorted Dinner Rolls with Butter

per dozen
$5.50

Eggplant Parmesan

Half Tray
$50
Full Tray
$100

Assorted Roasted Vegetables

Minimum 5lbs.
per pound
$7.95

Seasoned Yellow or White Rice

Half Tray
$30
Full Tray
$60

Sauteed Broccoli

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Sauteed Peas, Mushrooms & Pearl Onions

Half Tray
$40
Full Tray
$80

Mashed or Garlic Potatoes

Half Tray
$35
Full Tray
$65

Macaroni Salad

per pound
$3

Cole Slaw

per pound
$3

Dijon Potato Salad

With eggs.
per pound
$4.95

German Potato Salad

No mayo.
per pound
$4.95

Sliced Foccacia Bread

Topped with your choice of Caramelized Onions or Rosemary & Parmesan or Tomato & Basil or Pesto Glaze. One topping choice only.
half sheet
$24.95

This is our standard food by the tray catering menu. This menu is subject to change. Please contact us if you’re looking for something that’s not listed on the menu.